The four ratings

Mood

Mood, 1 to 5

How the story sits with you once you close it. A 1 is a book you forget by dinner; a 5 lingers for days, and a middle score means a pleasant read that didn't stick.

Maturity

Maturity, Yes or Mostly

Are the leads adults, written and drawn as adults? "Yes" means every main character is a grown-up in both story and art. "Mostly" flags a single ambiguous case, which we always explain in the review.

Content notes

Content notes, Light to Heavy

What's actually on the page: Light, Some, or Heavy, covering intimacy, violence, and emotional intensity. A content note is information, not a spoiler, and a high story score never cancels it out.

Story

Story, 1 to 5

How well the book is made: plot, pacing, character arcs, and craft in both script and art. This score is independent of mood, so a sharp, well-built story can still leave you cold, and we will say so.

Our standard

Four rules we never bend

Grown-up characters only. No school settings. A clear content note on every review. Official releases only. These are the non-negotiables behind every score we publish.